Restaurants in City Island, NY


Top Restaurants in City Island, NY



Restaurants in City Island, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant

Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant

41 City Island Ave, Bronx


This is the kind of seafood restaurant (nautical fixtures, lobster newburg, crab legs by the kilo, tartar sauce) that they are thinking of when they say "old school." And where…
more

40.838903 -73.783647
Artie's Steak & Seafood

Artie's Steak & Seafood

394 City Island Ave, Bronx


Their advertising is unclear about their parking.....my one bedroom apartment is bigger than their parking lot....heavily over priced....and small portions for the asking…
more

40.849645 -73.787258
The Black Whale

The Black Whale

279 City Island Ave, Bronx


I am never disappointed when I go to the Black Whale. The service is always great, the food is always delicious and the price is always right. They have an extensive menu, but i…
more

40.846376 -73.786322
J P's Restaurant

J P's Restaurant

703 Minnieford Ave, Bronx


One of my favorite restaurants in City Island. My entire family comes here for special occasions since the 80's. They have the best garlic bread ever!! Portions are huge and the…
more

40.857566 -73.790562
Portofino Restaurant

Portofino Restaurant

555 City Island Ave, Bronx


amazing service, great ambiance and definitely a standout on city island. a lot of places are cheap (ghetto) seafood dives but portofino definitely keeps it classy. food was fresh…
more

40.853253 -73.790882
City Island Lobster House

City Island Lobster House

691 Bridge St Ste 1, Bronx


Here's the deal with City Island: it's a remote, isolated place but rarely visited by Manhattanites. Even people from the Bronx rarely go there. But when you do go there, whether…
more

40.85673 -73.791023
The Original Crab Shanty

The Original Crab Shanty

361 City Island Ave, Bronx


THE GOOD: this place has really good seafood particularly the king crab legs, lobster and jumbo shrimp. nice big portions, the meal specials for 2 really feed 4 people. service was…
more

40.848671 -73.787161
Ohana

Ohana

500 City Island Ave, Bronx


Very entertaining, I was very pleased with the service and the food. I've been there about 3 times so far. There's a DJ that plays great music there at night on weekends now. I…
more

40.852141 -73.788976
Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina

Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina

591 City Island Ave, Bronx


La Villa is my go to place for business lunches, and weeknight dinners with my family. I have been going there since it first opened and the food has NEVER let me down. The setting…
more

40.852818 -73.789694
Tapas City Island

Tapas City Island

435 City Island Avenue, Bronx


This place sucks ROYALLY!!! I went with my out of town friends and my wife because we heard they had good Pina Coladas and the place next door (Sea Food City)(which has excellent…
more

40.850692 -73.788502

View More Restaurants

Recent Guides

View More Guides

Best of Citysearch

View All Best Restaurants

Expert Scout Reviews


Johnny's Famous Reef Rstrnt. City Island, an isolated fishing community in the Bronx, exists pretty much outside of time, and so does its most famous restaurant, the eternally enjoyable Johnny's. This isn't the greatest seafood in the world, to be honest. But it's the greatest seafood experience in New York.… read more