Restaurants in Coney Island, NY


Recommended by Our Experts

The Original Nathan's Famous Est. 1916

The Original Nathan's Famous Est. 1916

Brooklyn, NY

It's not a trip to Coney Island without a stop here -- even vegetarians will swoon over lemonade and crispy fries.

Top Restaurants in Coney Island, NY



Restaurants in Coney Island, NY
Popeye's Chicken & Biscuits

Popeye's Chicken & Biscuits

3004 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn


In ShortThis Cajun-style fast food restaurant first opened in New Orleans in 1972 and has since achieved domestic and international fame for its flavorful mild and spicy chicken.…
more

40.575397 -73.981097
Mcdonald's

Mcdonald's

606 Neptune Ave. @ West 6th Street, Brooklyn


In ShortThe intoxicating smell of golden fries cooked to crispy perfection and succulent burgers sizzling on the grill permeates the space, while a lively chatting and munching…
more

40.580976 -73.974594
Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano

1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn


Generations of New Yorkers have finished off their Coney Island beach days (and sometimes snow days) with a trip to one of the pizza greats, Totonno's on Neptune Avenue.
more

40.578923 -73.983834
The Original Nathan's Famous Est. 1916

The Original Nathan's Famous Est. 1916

1310 Surf Ave, Brooklyn


The epicenter of hot dogs, New York City's beach culture, and ridiculous eating challenges is at Nathan's Famous on Surf Avenue.
more

40.575514 -73.98168
Riviera Grill & Sushi

Riviera Grill & Sushi

3100 Ocean Pkwy, Brooklyn


"This place has the best sushi that I have had in New York, ever. Overall I would definitely place in my favorite 3 spots for sushi of all time. The presentation and flavors were…
more

40.575876 -73.969353
Gargiulo's Restaurant

Gargiulo's Restaurant

2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn


When Brooklyn's Italian-Americans want to enjoy a nice relaxing meal in Coney Island, they stop by Gargoiulo's. The menu's a bit pricey, but you won't find better baked clams…
more

40.5765 -73.982494
Rocco's Famous Pizzaria

Rocco's Famous Pizzaria

522 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn


I have been eating there my whole life. They have such awesome pizza! I haven't actually ate something there that I didn't like. All my friends go to Rocco's on Neptune Ave…
more

40.579825 -73.973294
Starbucks Coffee

Starbucks Coffee

3035 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn


I have been going here since it first came into the neighborhood. The staff continues to be friendly and remembers my usual order. The product is consistent and enjoyable way to…
more

40.580959 -73.985604
Famous Rottiserie & Grill

Famous Rottiserie & Grill

1525 Mermaid Ave, Brooklyn


This hole in the wall joint is surprisingly good. The rotisserie chicken is famous.
more

40.57689 -73.983545
Wildwood Rotisserie

Wildwood Rotisserie

1204 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn


I've lived in Brooklyn my entire life, i truly thought I had seen everything that Coney Island had to offer, till some friends who live in the area clued me in on this place. Their…
more

40.579276 -73.979859

View More Restaurants

Recent Guides

View More Guides

Best of Citysearch

View All Best Restaurants

Expert Scout Reviews


Denny's Delight Inc. Walk along Surf Avenue and you'll happen upon Denny's, a tiny booth serving up fried delights and better soft serve frozen custard than anything else you'll find on the boardwalk.… read more


The Original Nathan's Famous Est. 1916. Nathan's is a piece of living history: it's one of the only relics of Coney Island past. Oh, and the hot dogs aren't too shabby either. … read more


Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano. For my money, this was always the best of the coal-oven pantheon pizzas, a thinner, lighter, more restrained pie than the big thick pies produced by John's, et. al. The Coney Island location makes it special too; as with Midwood's Di Fara, the trip makes you appreciate the experience even more. … read more