Hotels & Motels in Montauk, NY


Recommended by Our Experts

The Surf Lodge

The Surf Lodge

Montauk, NY

Stop by on Sunday nights to catch some of the best indie bands in the business, for free. Otherwise, try to dodge the lodge on the weekends.

Top Hotels & Motels in Montauk, NY



Hotels & Motels in Montauk, NY
The Surf Lodge

The Surf Lodge

183 Edgemere Street, Montauk


Stop by on Sunday nights to catch some of the best indie bands in the business, for free. Otherwise, try to dodge the lodge on the weekends.
more

41.037847 -71.945139
Harborside Resort Motel

Harborside Resort Motel

371 W Lake Dr, Montauk


I stayed overnight at Harborside, and it was one of the worst experiences I ever had. There were bees, moths and mosquitos in the room. The plates inside the kitchen area were…
more

41.067698 -71.940897
Gurney's Inn Resrt Spa

Gurney's Inn Resrt Spa

290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk


its a hidden treasure! luxurious & beautiful overlooking the ocean...products & services are so trend setting..the best most thorough pedicure manicure ever...renowned for the…
more

41.015365 -71.991796
Montauket Hotel

Montauket Hotel

88 Firestone Rd, Montauk


Order some rum punch and enjoy the sunset from the best view in all of Montauk.
more

41.054107 -71.957343
Hartman's Briney Breezes Motel

Hartman's Briney Breezes Motel

693 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk


This motel was both clean and affordable and the staff was very friendly. The heated outdoor pool and the balcony overlooking the ocean were wonderful. The beach is conveniently…
more

41.027589 -71.962544
Memory Motel

Memory Motel

692 Montauk Hwy, Montauk


The Rolling Stones set a song in this motel for a reason: it's full of character. The Memory is a bar with motel rooms to crash in, and that's just one of the reasons The Memory is…
more

41.033042 -71.946441
Montauk Motel

Montauk Motel

76 S Edison St, Montauk


We stayed at the Montauk Manor for two weeks. It was fabulous. Our room was clean, beautifully furnished and had a gorgeous water view. The lobby is amazing...two huge…
more

41.037302 -71.942972
Sea Crest on the Ocean

Sea Crest on the Ocean

2166 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett


Went out this weekend for Mothers day. We rented two units. It was really nice and new just like the website bloggers said. We stayed in one ocean front upper unit (35), and the…
more

41.001356 -72.030535
Port Royal Hotel

Port Royal Hotel

Navy Rd, Montauk


The Port Royal offers an alternative to the busier and trendier ocean side of Montauk, a refuge if you will. The pool is new and very well maintained . They also offer a new…
more

41.041767 -71.964569
Driftwood Motel & Cottages

Driftwood Motel & Cottages

2178 Montauk Hwy, Montauk


You don't have to rent a house on Georgica for beachfront views--opt for a cozy cottage in the dunes off Montauk Highway, and get away for a weekend or a week.
more

41.001818 -72.028934

View More Hotels & Motels

Recent Guides

View More Guides

Expert Scout Reviews


Memory Motel. The Rolling Stones set a song in this motel for a reason: it's full of character. The Memory is a bar with motel rooms to crash in, and that's just one of the reasons The Memory is the place for a summer bender.… read more