Restaurants in Shelter Island Heights, NY


Top Restaurants in Shelter Island Heights, NY



Restaurants in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Sunset Beach Restaurant

Sunset Beach Restaurant

37 Shore Rd, Shelter Isle HTS


We ate lunch at the restaurant and they slipped a $52 bottle wine charge on our bill which we never ordered. I called to give them a chance to correct the "mistake" but they didn't…
more

41.074077 -72.361843
Michael Anthony's At Dering

Michael Anthony's At Dering

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Isle Hts



more

41.082824 -72.347433
Dory

Dory

114 Bridge St, Shelter Island



more

41.083686 -72.351301
On Onshore

On Onshore

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Isle Hts



more

41.082824 -72.347398
Olde Country Inn

Olde Country Inn

11 Stearns Pt Rd, Shelter Island



more

41.072955 -72.360399
Sweet Tomato's

Sweet Tomato's

15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island



more

41.083386 -72.354983
Southold Fish Market

Southold Fish Market

61850 Route 25, Southold


Best fish around! Yum.
more

41.074774 -72.426102
Antares Cafe

Antares Cafe

2530 Manhasset Ave, Greenport


You can't walk there from the ferry but it's a quick drive to the marina...the resturant is right in the middle of a boat yard, outdoor seating with heat lamps and a small indoor…
more

41.110238 -72.35531
Vine Street Cafe

Vine Street Cafe

41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island


$9.00 for a basic salad (costs go up from here). An alcoholic drink costs $10.00. A glass of Pinot Grigio wine costs $9.00. A glass of Sambuca costs $9.00. Good food,…
more

41.059814 -72.325568
Hellenic Snackbar & Restaurant

Hellenic Snackbar & Restaurant

5145 Main Rd, East Marion


Driving to the end of Long Island can be long, and very interesting, because of the sites. I stopped off at this little restaurant not knowing what to expect and my expectations…
more

41.12003 -72.350602

View More Restaurants