Hotels & Motels in Shelter Island, NY


Top Hotels & Motels in Shelter Island, NY



Hotels & Motels in Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Hideaway

Shelter Island Hideaway

1 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island Heights


Seclusion, Romance, Beach, Pools, all here on Shelter Island This summer I wanted to take my husband for a vacation in the Hamptons Searching the Internet I found this Caribbean…
more

41.058062 -72.369048
Azalea House

Azalea House

1 Thomas Ave, Shelter Island


Stayed here in August 2012. It's an excellent budget B&B on Shelter Island. We managed to book a last minute room in the high season for $200 a night. That's darn cheap for Shelter…
more

41.068544 -72.33584
House On Chase Creek

House On Chase Creek

3 Locust Ave, Shelter Isle HTS


Easy to get to via LIRR & ferry (make sure you have 2 dollars in change for ferry token), Sharon was kind enough to pick us up from the ferry, even though we arrived at around…
more

41.081502 -72.352374
Shelter Island Hideaway

Shelter Island Hideaway

1 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island


Wonderful, romantic, secluded, relaxing Shelter Island cottage. In reality, calling this cottage wonderful is an immense understatement. The beautiful grounds and the pond,…
more

41.047091 -72.354436
Sunset Beach Motel

Sunset Beach Motel

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Isle Hts



more

41.074085 -72.361322
Dering Harbor Inn

Dering Harbor Inn

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Isle HTS



more

41.082824 -72.347398
Chequit Inn

Chequit Inn

23 Grand Ave, Shelter Isle HTS



more

41.08387 -72.355108
The Pridwin Hotel

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Rd, Shelter Island



more

41.069253 -72.374854
Belle Crest House

Belle Crest House

163 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Isle HTS


Just returned from a wonderful weekend at the Belle Crest House. Lots of charm and comfort abound throughout the house. Someone was always available to answer questions or supply…
more

41.082484 -72.350132
Winthrop Manor Ltd

Winthrop Manor Ltd

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Isle Hts



more

41.082824 -72.347398

View More Hotels & Motels