Market Street Oyster Bar

(801) 531-6044 | View Website

54 W Market St, Salt Lake City, UT | Directions   84101

40.761744 -111.892871

Open Hours

Sat: 3pm-10:30pm, Sun: 10am-3pm, 3pm-10:30pm, Mon-Fri: 3pm-10:30pm, 11:30am-2pm

Restaurants, Seafood, Eclectic & International  more

Price: $$$

Tags: Bar Scene, Brunch, Business Dining, Celeb Hangout, Dine At The Bar, Fine Dining, Late Night Dining, People Watching

Payment Methods: American Express, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Neighborhoods: Rio Grande

Hand-Squeezed Orange & Grapefruit Juices, Seasonal Fruit 3.90, Dish of Seasonal Mixed Berries, Sliced Bananas, Whole Jumbo Sectioned Grapefruit, Whole Jumbo Sectioned Grapefruit w/ Brulee Crust, Tavern Ham, Bacon, Sausage or Ground Beef Patty, Scrambled Eggs, Two Hot Cakes w/ Bacon, Ham or Sausage, Two Eggs Benedict... more

Reviews for Market Street Oyster Bar

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Bartenders Cold Shoulder – My fiance and I have been going to the Market Street Oyster Bar for years now. We've always appreciated the restaurants amazing atmosphere and its excellent customer service. The food is great and the drinks are too. We are kinda late night goers so on the average we usually end up make out way to O.B. probably the last hour to 2 hours before close. We've noticed these last six months or more that the food has stayed the same but the customer service at the bar has certainly gone down. The bar tenders, the female bar tenders more so then the males, will make you drinks but a lot of the time you have to get their attention and it progressively gets worse as it approaches closing hour. Towards the last hour it seems that they are put out that you are ordering another drink, you practically have to wave a red flag to get their attention cause they intentionally go out of their way to keep their back to you or congregate if the managers not around. I've always felt welcome to ask the kettle cooks to get me another drink but am usually disappointed to find that they have to get the unfriendly bar tender who gets to collect the tip-seems to me maybe the kettle cooks should become the bar tenders since they seem to be a lot more cordial then the bar tenders are )-:

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Great drinks, but way over rated food. – I've been going to the Market Street Oyster Bar and Grill for many years and although the staff is great and the drinks are good the food however is glorified Denny's. It's so stuck in the 80's and is resistant to change.

Note to the owner...what worked 30 years ago was great...then but now it's tired. Let the kitchen update your menu, it's becoming embarrasing for you and besides the oysters and cocktails there is really no reason for us to keep buying your outdated schtick any longer. I know you have talent in the back of the house and you should allow them more specials and change out some of your menu items. Keep some of the clasics like the clam chowder and fish and chips, but update the menu! PLEASE!!! I mean Broiled Mahi-Mahi with a slab of pineapple on it? Grilled Halibut with run of the mill Tartar Sauce? Everything and it's brother or sister slathered with hollandaise that sits too long under the heat lamps, thus becoming like an omlet perched on your meal....? See what I mean about glorified Denny's? You have seriously lost your edge and are in danger of becoming irrelevant. You have a great staff, that is actually trained, a definte big plus for Utah. You have a beautiful decor with all the glass and chrome, but don't stop there and hang onto your laurels hoping no one will notice. We do. The restaurant biz is like a swimming shark once you've stopped moving forward you start to sink and die. Get out once in a while and visit other up and coming places that continue to grow and get better. Get inspiration from where ever you can you desperately need it.

Jim (02/16/11) I'm sorry to say about your review, it does get better, alot better. Try any seafood place in any other major city in the United States and you will see what I mean. Heck, try Park City for a change like Wahso or Grapa that are trying to stay in the same culinary century.

Getting back to the owner (Gastronomy)...since you are a chain and hope to expand check out what they are doing at McCormick & Schmick's, The Palm or Pappadeaux Seafood Kitchens.

You have a great thing going, but if any of the above were to set up shop here you would be done inside 3-4 years. My advice, get out of your office and talk to the know the ones in the actual restaurants??? and you will find they agree with me.

over a year ago

Doesn't get much better – I have been coming here for years. It is a great place to come with friends or to meet new ones. Also, a great place to be seen at. Food is fresh, service is friendly. What they do works and it shows. This place has been a popular spot for both regulars and business travelers for about 30 years.

Keep up the good work.

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Great Food, Great Staff, Horrible Manager – I have been a regular at the Downtown Oyster Bar for several years now. My husband and I went in before a Jazz game for dinner a few weeks ago and we sat at the bar as we usually do. The bartender was fantastic and our dinner was amazing as always, however we were extremely offended on how we witness the manager Todd Johnson treat the bartender. My husband and myself thought right away that this man doesn't respect his employees and especially doesn't know how to treat a female employee. I can hear him reprimanding the bartender and threaten to fire her right in front of us. I am not sure what the reasoning behind it was but we know that bartender did not deserve such treatment and we can see her crying after this Manager left. I personally was very offended and outraged at such an incident. The service has always been great from this Bartender and she has always made my husband and I feel at home everytime we come in.

Although we love the food and staff, we decided to not to return and support such harassment by this manager and the company that hired him.

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Do Not Go There!!! – One time I went there and they ran out of pasta and had to cook more. Thankfully the manager let us off the meal for free. Don't eat there, I'm sorry, It is not worth paying the price for the seafood there. First we live in Utah and even if the seafood can get here quickly, it is not worth freakin $40 a plate. Plus the Oysters are not that good for the price they ask ( pretty petite oysters "where is it"). There tends to be partygoers there at the bar, then the others that eat at the tables. It is just as easy to cook a nice juicy stake at home for $25, than pay an outrageous $45 or $50, whatever the price is for that matter.

*I was at the counter one night and I saw a waiter and he had a hand-cloth tucked in the back of his pants and it looked like he might have had a small blood stain ( don't take my total word for it )

*Way over-rated, especially the one in Cottonwood area in SLC, Utah.

* Valet Parking, PLEASE!!!

Don't waste your money on this business, go eat somewhere else.

over a year ago

good vibes – Every time I visit the oyster bar,I asked for Richelle to be my server

she's the best. The seafood is great.and a good bar too.

Its the place to see and be seen.

over a year ago

Great Service – The Market Street Oyster Bar has the best service in town. If you looking for a restaurant where you can relax, have a few drinks and get your food fast and fresh this is the place to go. I swear there's no such thing as a bad day to the servers here. They always greet you with a smile and continue to make the entire experience here delightful, especially Aaron, who serves during the day. I recomend anyone to go here any time of day. The food may not be the best, but the service and drinks make up for the food.

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Never again! – Coming from the Atlantic Coast where good seafood is plentiful and great, I would rate this as a sad place for seafood. Everything is overpriced for the quality of ingredients and cooking that you are getting in return. I was very surprised that this place has received high reviews and was as crowded as it was the night we visited. The seafood was skimpy and not expertly cooked, the prices are too high, and the service too slow- although not inattentive. Expect to stay a good 3 hours for a full course dinner. The only good thing about this restaurant is the atmosphere and selection of beers and wines. I'm glad we only paid for a temporary membership because we won't be returning.

over a year ago

Hmm.. Going downhill? – First off i am a gastronomy member and frequent the oyster bar at least once or twice a month with friends or my wife. Usually we stick with King Crab, Chowder, Oysters and Champagne. That is all good, bill can get high with the booze bill- to be expeccted. What sucks about this place IMO is if you venture off of that path and go for their fish or standard appetizers you end up with food that is better suited for a mass market place like Red Lobster. $23-$26 a pop, small portions masked by steamed veggies and boring rice. Bottom line they need to innovate and revamp the menu (same for the last 5 years) and maybe get a new chef otherwise you are getting screwed.

over a year ago

See and be seen while dining on delicious seafood in a colorful and lively atmosphere. – The Scene
High ceilings, large mirrors, polished wood and brightly painted murals provide a sophisticated look. Sit at the bar or in one of the elevated tables. A full liquor license and savvy bartenders make this a favorite meeting spot for drinks and hors d'oeuvres.

The Food
The focus here is seafood, although the filet is popular as well. Daily seafood specials are based on what's flown in fresh. Shrimp, lobster, crab, mussel, oyster and clam dishes are always on the menu. Favorites include the cioppino (a spicy tomato broth with a variety of fish and shellfish) and the mussel stew, with a thick, creamy base and tomatoes, potatoes and onions. There are also burgers and sandwiches--try the crab and avocado. A variety of salads includes everything from blackened chicken on spinach to the tasty seafood cobb salad.

View more Reviews for Market Street Oyster Bar

Write a Review for

Market Street Oyster Bar

62% 100 23 21 Votes

Best of Citysearch

Won for:
Singles Scene (2006)
Nominations Nominated for:
After-Work Bar (2007)
Singles Scene (2007)
After-Work Bar (2006)
Bar Menu (2006)
Martini (2006)
Seafood (2006)
Bar Menu (2005)
Late-Night Dining (2005)
Martini (2005)
Seafood (2005)
Singles Scene (2005)
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of Market Street Oyster Bar to Citysearch

Do you have a review of Market Street Oyster Bar on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your Market Street Oyster Bar review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the Market Street Oyster Bar page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

Market Street Oyster Bar on Citysearch