Milk And Sugar Cafe

(631) 969-3655 | View Website

49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY | Directions   11706

40.720805 -73.248691

Open Hours

Mon. - Thu. 9am - 10pm;Fri. - Sat. 9am - 11pm;Sun. 9am - 1pm

Restaurants, American Express, MasterCard  more

More Payment Methods: Visa

Neighborhoods: Long Island

Main Street, The Bay Shore, Milk & Sugar, The Leo, The Lola, The Louis, Big Daddy, Plain Jayne, Farmer Don Omelette, The Molly Anne... more

Reviews for Milk And Sugar Cafe

over a year ago

Ordered takeout from this cute little place. – I ordered Lunch to go. The waitress who took my order was delightful giving me her suggestion for a lunch I wouldn't soon forget. The wrap was delicious and came with a fresh salad,plus they had sweet potato fries YUM! Overall excellent service and quality of the food. Two thumbs up.

over a year ago

Never a Bad Meal – We absolutely love Milk & Sugar Cafe. Have been to the cafe on multiple occasions and have ordered the catering for special events. The catering is fabulous, they deliver and setup everything for you. The cafe is also great for a date or a girls night out. Be patient. It is popular and wait times may occur during busy Saturday nights. (We normally take a walk around town)

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE – The service was terrible.

The manager/owner was a piece of work. She was rude and very unprofessional

We had no silverware, had to wait five minutes after getting our food to get silverware.

My friend ordered a hamburger medium rare, it was well done, sent it back, came back again well done. Returned it again, only to wait another twenty minutes to be served another well done hamburger.

Prior to my friend getting her third well done hamburger, I called the manager over. She came clumping over with her hands folded as if we were annoying her. We tried to explain what was happening and she just put her hands up and said this is the first time she was hearing about it. She kept asking my friend if she wanted her lunch or did she want it thrown out or donated to the local church. What a thing to say.

She then went back to the kitchen only to bring back the third well done hamburger which my friend returned.

I ordered a hamburger with fried onions and sweet potatoe fries, got the hamburger but no onions and no fries. Sent it back, they eventually brought me what I wanted, it was just cold.

I put my fork down as you should between bits, and twice a different bus boy asked me if I was done. I was no where near finished eating.

The bus boys were sweeping the floors as we were eating, which I feel is gross.

Apparently this manager is not to much into customer service.

over a year ago

Girls Day Out – My sorority sister suggested that we visit this quaint little cafe. I thought it was the cutest thing. The service could have been a little faster but my meal was great.

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Overrated, Mediocre & a Waste – Had lunch here on saturday. Here's a synopsis: Wait? Told 40 minutes, was actually 1 hour 15 minutes. Horrible Service: 15 minutes to wait for water. Order: After waiting 45 minutes, a CHEESEburger ordered Medium Rare came out a burnt charcoal of a burger, no cheese. Coffee drinks (ordered without whipped cream) came WITH whipped cream, but no espresso shots in them. This place is all smoke and mirrors. If the food and service was any good, they wouldn't need all the cheesy faux bed and breakfast decor (e.g. antique sewing machine in restroom (?!?) The only reason this place is popular is because it's on Long Island - it would be a miserable failure in any metropolis.


Write a Review for

Milk And Sugar Cafe

60% 100 14 5 Votes
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of Milk And Sugar Cafe to Citysearch

Do you have a review of Milk And Sugar Cafe on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your Milk And Sugar Cafe review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the Milk And Sugar Cafe page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

Milk And Sugar Cafe on Citysearch