Babylon >Food & Dining > Argyle Grill & Tavern
90 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY | Directions 1170240.698015 -73.323285
Mon - Thu, 11:30am - 2am (kitchen open till midnight); Fri - Sat, 11:30am - 3am (kitchen open till 1am); Sun, brunch 11am - 3pm, dinner 4pm - 11pm
Neighborhoods: Long Island, Asharoken
Great Meal – Wow, we went here for the first time last month. The skirt steak I had was amazing. My friend liked his seafood dish as well. We had some chocolate dessert, it was delishh.
However good the food was I don't think we'll return on a weekend night. It was extremely crowded and very, very loud. We were sat at a very small table in the dining room. It was way too close to the tables next to us, I hate that.
Our waitress was fine, not very friendly but she got everything right.
Sooo overall great food, not so great atmosphere unless of course you are at the bar throwing them back too!
Horrible steak! – Looks beautiful from the outside and has a really nice ambiance; however, the food was terrible. I went there for my anniversary and thought it would be nice to treat myself to filet minion. I never thought such a fine piece of meat could be so bad. First, I asked for my meat medium-well, I received well done. Second, the sauce wasn't very good. After eating 1/3 of the meat (cutting it thinking maybe the middle would have some pink) I informed the waitress. She came back after speaking with the chef and told me, "sorry, there's nothing we can do". I've been to sports bars that have been more consideration of my satisfaction. I give the entire experience an F. If you must go there the pomegranate martini was delicious. Too bad the bartender wasn't cooking the food!
UGH! – I cannot not believe that the place was so busy, oh right that was the bar, you coudl'nt hear anyone talking in the dinning room, probably because the food stunk.
Calamari- under cooked. Steak over cooked, St.Peters Fish - BLESSED WITH lipton onion soup mix.
Dessert lump of hot chocolate mess. Thank goodness the food looked good, because after the waitress gave us the food, and left. She was very pleasant, b ut she kept itching her body, ...wonder if it was the food.
Busy Restaurant – This restaurant has good food, not great. This is also a little expensive for dinner. I normally go for happy hour any day of the week. They have GREAT watermelon martinis with fresh watermelon slices on the rim of each glass.
It's good, not great. – I ate here for the first time 2 years ago and couldn't get enough of it. Everything was so good for a price worth paying. I've probably eaten here 30+ times. For the past year the prices have gone up and the food quality has gone down. I hardly go anymore because I've been very disappointed with the food the past 4 or 5 times and feel like the price is not worth it. Quite the opposite of 2 years ago.
Also, this place is very noisy. Don't expect to have a conversation at your table unless you want to yell at each other.
Go for lunch first and decide if you want to go back for dinner.
The Argyle in Babylon – Awesome gathering spot, the chef does an incredible job. Must try the Chilean Sea Bass or the marinated porterhouse steak. Fantastic watermelon martini's and a great wine list. Service is friendly and efficient. The decor is warm and inviting. Definetly recommend this restaurant located in the quaint little village of Babylon.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Argyle Grill & Tavern on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.