4082 Nesconset Hwy, East Setauket, NY | Directions 1173340.904692 -73.072203
Daily, 10am - 10pm
Neighborhoods: Selden, Long Island
SETAUKET PASTARIA – HORRIBLE SERVICE, FOOD TERRIBLE.. i called for a delivery at 9pm and the guy who answered the phone said "are you kidding me i cant belive you want a delivery this late i was just about to go home" unreal.. the pizza sucks the food even worse. they say "the best chefs" lol not even close.. and the manager "richie" when i called after the guy was an a$$ hole would not talk to me he put everybody els on the phone but him.. place is a joke dont wast your time
Terrible Management – We order here often from work and there is usually a problem with the order. Just recently the so called "manager" Richard missed a drink order and he would not own up to his mistake. He called three times insisting we owed him $1.47. He sent the delivery boy back to retrieve the money and when we refused to pay for something we didn't receive, he threatened to take it out of the poor delivery boys pay. HEY SETAUKET PASTARIA- FIRE THIS GUY! HE IS CREEPY, RUDE AND JUST COST YOU BUSINESS!
awesome food – i love to eat out. this local place is the greatest. i just stop in and the service is quick and i leave really full! they have like 9 different pizzas. the taco pie is awesome! i've tried the dining room too and the black lobster ravioli with jumbo shrimp is my favorite...
Much more than a pizzeria – I am a regular at Setauket Pastaria for many reasons...the wide variety of fresh pizzas and rolls, the friendly, prompt service and the beautiful decor. We have also used them for off premise catering and were equally pleased. I've attended a large party in the dining room and the food was delicious! Generous portions and fresh ingredients. You would never think all this exists tucked away in a shopping center. I recommened Setauket Pastaria 100%!
best pizza on li, by a mile – i love pizza. one of the greatest foods created. this place is a must if you to love pizza. i had to join CitySearch and leave a review when i saw 2 bad reviews on this site. maybe they're the competition. see for yourself. i've been a customer for many years and i've never had a problem. very friendly. most variety in pizzas. atmosphere is second to none.
HIGHLY OVERATTED – Really was disappointed. Starting with the email on their site to make reservations which turns out to be an autoresponse and does not give you a reservation. Then when I made a reservation telling them it was my 34th wedding anniversary and I wanted a particular table they said it would be no problem. When I arrived there was no reservation and my table was taken. The waterboy did not refill water, the free wine night had to be asked for or it was not given, the wine was less than average, the veal was tough and grisly, the fried appetizer had cold mozzarella, undercooked zuccinni and overcooked shrimp. All in all it was a very mediocre and forgettable experience. I would never recommend it to anyone.
Highly Recommended – This place is something special, hidden in an average shopping center. It was like walking into another world. you really need to check this place out. The pizza was great. Best salad slice i've had. Great selection. I also had a chicken marsala slice, i splurged. Can't wait to have dinner there.
Looks nice, but that's it... – Justed moved to town, looking for a good Pizza Place. This one looks great, but two bad experiences will keep me away. Service not too good and the pizza is below average unless you're getting a regular cheese pie. Also very pricey....$20 for a vegetable pie that was probably about the worst i've had. Guess i'll keep looking for another place.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Setauket Pastaria on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.