Seattle >Food & Dining > Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway
426 Broadway Ave. E., Seattle, WA | Directions 9810247.625364 -122.321321
Neighborhoods: Broadway, Capitol Hill
They like to remind you that the "g' is silent. Silent or not, this place has been serving up happy Seattleites one slice at a time for more than 30 years. They must be doing something right.
Pagliacci's Rarely Disappoints – Fresh mushrooms - Walla Walla sweets, gently caramelized - don't forget that they have oustanding pep and sausage, too! We've been ordering from Pag's since they started. Sure, you occasionally get a bad one, but the crust is always the best, sauce occasionally variable, ingredients are the freshest and generally not overdone (no "10-lb" pizzas here, just plenty of quality). And, the driver's are invariably relaxed and friendly. Thankully, new ownership doesn't seem to have changed the pizza or delivery!
You call this pizza – I've been here for a little over a year and I have yet to find anything that slightly resembles a pizza, round is about the only resemblance. I come from upstate NY, Rochester and any comparison to a pizza from NY is a laugh. The dough has no flavor the sauce is a bland tomato paste and there is no such thing an italian sausage or peperonni on any pizzza that I've had out here. I've tried Pagliacci and about a dozen other pies and I will save my money and have a pie overnighted from back east. Stick to the salmon.
Heavyweight Champion – After all these years and acolades, Still Pagliacci Pizza is by far the best Pizza in our town.
One would thing by now, we would all be tried of the same old-pizza. But, No, it just seems to keep it's old favorite flavor fresh. An we keep coming back for more slices.
Yummy! Yummy! Yummy! – Pagliacci Pizza is one of my favorites in town. It's one of the best New York style pizzas in Seattle, next to Guido's Pizza. Pagliacci Pizza also has a really good Pagliacci Salad. It's a MUST if you like salads with your pizza, and isn't the typical green house salad. Their cheese pizza is fantastico!
Yummy! – Love the varieties of pizza, and they don't hassle you if you want to substitute or remove a topping. The crust is so good, and I never liked crust before! I always gave it to my dog...The vegetables taste fresh and meats are cooked to perfection, even with a hint of marinade. Good job, guys!!
Too messy! – Way too much cheese on a slippery sauce, I've been to Pagliaccis a couple of times and both times needed to shower afterwards it was so messy. The flavour wasn't anything spectacular either.
Try Piecoras for a better meal.
Grab a cheap slice of heaven – Pagliacci is one of the best of the Old Seattle Stand-by's for a quick and cheap bite. The food isn't always the greatest, but it's always there, and if nothing else, it's consistent. With a reasonable selection of good beer and by-the-slice semi-fresh pizza, even though it's not best, it got me through college.
Pizza is overrated, way too expensive, occassionally forgets their order and the delivery drivers are extremely dangerous
Pag's and Coconut Gelato – Unquestionalbly the best pie around. Fresher ingredients, hot to your door and make with love. Redefines quality pizza. With the addition of gelato to a meal what more could you ask for?
Not bad, not great. – This pizza is all right. The veggies are good and they don't skimp on cheese or sauce. Just don't judge it by the standards New Yorker's are always going off about. It's not the best around, but it's definitely worth ordering once in a while.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.