Brandon >Restaurants >
Pizza >New York Times Square Pizza
927 E. Bloomingdale Ave., Brandon, FL | Directions 3351127.893724 -82.269545
Mon - Sat, 11am - 10pm; Sun, 11am - 9pm
disgusting food – went there with a coupon from restaurantdotcom and turns out thats also a scam. this place was the nastiest food ive ever put it in my mouth. the place was dirty (shouldve left when i saw that) the guy was nice but the food took about 45 mins to come out and was DISGUSTING!!! WILL NEVER EAT THERE AGAIN!!!
Great Food! – We have had a few items from here...the wings are great (better than the local chain restaurants), the subs are AMAZING! They aren't huge, but they are full of flavor, and the rolls are genuine philly cheesesteak rolls. The pizza is good...I will drive the extra miles to have a pizza from here rather than get delivery (we are out of their delivery range).
The owner definitely isn't new to the industry...great customer service and he knows his way around the kitchen! As the only employee during our visit (mid afternoon on a monday), he made sure to perfectly time the delivery of the appetizers and the pizza.
New Ownership Really Makes A Difference – I love the veggie paninis! They make them just the way I like, sauteed veggies covered in provolone melted cheese, tucked neatly inside their very own spiced homemade bread. Just writing about them makes me hungry for another.
The whole place is taking on a fresh new look. Won't even recognize it in a couple of week.
The staff is young, friendly, and eager to please.
It's a great place to stop in for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner after work.
Pizza Without the New York In It – I am from northern jersey and luuuuuv New York style pizza- there is nothing like it. Tonight, my husband and I were ready for some butt-kicking pizza. New York Times Square's pizza is NOTHING CLOSE to it. The pizza was edible BUT needed a little more time to cook in the oven to give it some crisp and brown the cheese. Overall, it took on a flavor of a thawed out, store-bought pizza from Wal-Mart. I mean I was just so disappointed!! The wings had a nice flavor, but they needed to cook a little longer until the meat's a bit more tender. However, their customer service was fine.
great pizza, bad service. What a shame – this pizza is excellent, but do yourself a favor and pick it up yourself, as their delivery service is subpar and they have all the excuses in the world. Oh and while ordering, make sure you talk to a manager not a kid behind the counter.
Best NY pizza around – Being from the north, it has been hard for us to find GOOD pizza - until now. We ordered for delivery to try it - pretty quick service - and the food was SO good it is now our favorite place! The subs are HUGE - easily 2 meals in 1. Same with the pasta dinners. Highly recommend!
very bad service, extremly slow! – Very bad service. I orderd a large pizza and 12 wings, and never got it. 1 hr passed and I called to check the status and they said it had just left, another hour passed and I called and canceled. Their ad states fast delivery, apperantly not the case. DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM.
Great Pizza and Calzones – Great pizza and calzones and the pricing is very reasonable. The large calzones really would feed at least three people - great value for the price. But the best are the small calzones - perfect for one to eat and have some left over - they cook a bit more evenly because of the size (the larges are almost too big!). Also, they make the calzones with ricotta - like they should be - another plus. The pizza is also great and they deliver on orders over $10. There menu is pretty extensive as well - salads, dinners, dessert.... This is one of my favorite local places.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of New York Times Square Pizza on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.