My Pie Pizza Bucktown

(773) 394-6900 | View Website

2010 N Damen Ave, Chicago, IL | Directions   60647

41.918149 -87.677630

Open Hours

Monday - Saturday: 11am - 10:15pm

Sunday: 11am - 9pm

Delivery Hours:

Mon - Fri 11:30am-1:30pm & 5pm-10pm

Sat: Noon - 10pm

Sun: Noon - 8:45pm

Restaurants, Sandwich Shops, Corporate Catering  more

Payment Methods: MasterCard, Cash, Discover, Visa, American Express

Tags: Food Delivery, Carry Out

Cuisine: Pizza

Neighborhoods: North Side, Bucktown

Owner verified business
My Pie Pizza Bucktown
My Pie Pizza Bucktown
My Pie Pizza Bucktown
My Pie Pizza Bucktown

From The Owners of My Pie Pizza Bucktown

My Pie comes from a family recipe 40 years ago. Come celebrate 40 years of Chicago Pizza with us!

My Pie Mozzarella Garlic Bread, Spicy Garlic Bread, Dinner Salad- Combination of Seasonal Fresh, Mandarin Orange Salad, Caesar Salad, Cobb Salad, Chef's Salad, Cheese, Cheese, Cheese... more

Special Offers

  1. Print Offer

    Lunch Special- only $7.95!

    Provided by CityGrid

    Stop by any day and get our My Pie Pizza lunch special for only $7.95. Includes 1 slice, small salad bar and a fountain drink. Call us toll free for more details: (877) 474-8230.

  2. Print Offer

    Mondays & Tuesdays- Thin Crust Pizzas for only $6.95!

    Provided by CityGrid

    Mention Citysearch and get a SMALL thin crust pizza for only $6.95. Limit 2 per order. Must order on Monday & Tuesday.

Reviews for My Pie Pizza Bucktown

over a year ago

Fresh Ingredients/Fair Prices – In the last two weeks I've ordered pizza from My Pie. Both their thin crust pizza and chicago style deep dish pizza are very good. I've found them to be a lot cheaper than other pizza places in the city as well. My brother insisted on ordering from another pizza joint in our neighborhood, same size & ingredients, but My Pie's Pizza was $10 less and tasted better.

Also, my GF didn't want pizza last time I ordered, so she got a salad and soup from Lil Guys Deli which is in the same unit as My Pie, and they delivered together.

Awesome experience with My Pie Pizza. They gained a loyal customer and I would recommend them to anyone!

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

not unique; not even polite – first time reviewing; wish it was a rave. regarding my pie / lil guys: always liked the food -- the sandwiches -- unbelievable ultimate reuben on the weekends -- smoothies, and the pizza: crisp and tasty thin crust, buttery and not too rich deep dish. just called and ordered a pizza. very rude phone person -- and this wasn't the first time. so rude this time, i called back and canceled. i spend a few hundred bucks a year at my pie / lil guys, but this "bucktown service," as a friend of mine calls it... sheesh, i'm just sick of it. see, lou malnati's is in bucktown now, too. and my pie's deep dish pizza is a lot like lou's -- almost identical crust and sauce. and they don't give you "bucktown service." called them and they weren't open yet. then i remembered pequod's delivers to bucktown, too. so i ordered from there. there is an embarrassment of wealth regarding good pizza in this area. unless you have a jones for a truly unique delight, like john's thin crust on western, you do not have to put up with the "bucktown service" at my pie. my pie is not indispensable, and we are in a recession. i don't need you to love me, but blatant disdain when i'm saying please and thank you and i'm just trying to order a pizza? what's your problem?

over a year ago

Great Pizza...and the little freebie plastic pizza cutter works! – I was really surprised when the pizza guy rang the doorbell...he was there well under the time the place had told me. I got the deep dish and it was fantastic. I loved the crust and cheese. The sauce was really good, too. And, as a nice touch, they included a little freebie pizza cutter that actually worked! Definitely ordering again soon.

over a year ago

Amazing pizza and sandwiches – The one on Damen is great. Awful parking, but I usually get lucky and find a spot. Love the lunch special (slice of pizza and make-your-own salad). I usually don't care for slices, but My Pie's always seems delicious. And the Little Guy sandwiches are great also. I bought the Ham/Cheese on Hawaiian bread for several people at the office, and we all agree it's one of the best sandwiches we've ever had.

over a year ago

not worth it – VERY EXPENSIVE, went to the one on Clark and the pizza was not all of that, not worth what you pay, and the service was absolutely terrible (SLOW). First and last time for me, if you absolutely want to try it, I recommend a personal size for yourself, appetizers are very average but expesive as well.


Write a Review for

My Pie Pizza Bucktown

80% 100 6 5 Votes
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of My Pie Pizza Bucktown to Citysearch

Do you have a review of My Pie Pizza Bucktown on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your My Pie Pizza Bucktown review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the My Pie Pizza Bucktown page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

My Pie Pizza Bucktown on Citysearch