Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED (Reported Closed)

(212) 477-9950

349 E 12th St, New York, NY | Directions   10003

40.730700 -73.984601

 
Restaurants, $, Date Spot  more

More Tags: Family Style Dining, Local Favorite

Cuisine: Pizza

Payment Methods: Cash

Neighborhoods:

less
 
 

Reviews for Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

The best dough hands down – I'm fully aware Una Pizza closed last year, but seeing a low star rating is disgraceful for the grand city of food (or maybe we're slipping). The pies were the simplest I'd ever had anywhere in the states, but there was something about them that was off the charts. He took a lot of pride in his technique, ingredients, and equipment and should do well in San Fran. Motorino is excellent, but not on the same level as its predecessor.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Very expensive for poor quality – Una currently holds the title of worst pizza/experience in NYC. We arrived right when the place opened so we only had to wait 30min for the 12inch pie to arrive. The pizza was covered in water and only 1/2 the pizza actually had tomatoe sauce on it... so I'm not sure what I was paying for and I would have been better off at dominos!

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Excellent, but pricey – If you are into authentic neopolitin-style pizza, then this pizza is very, very, good. It might be the best I've ever had. But I travel around the country looking for this style of Pizza. If you're into classic New York, Chicago, California Gourmet, or Pizza Hut chain style pizzas - you'll be disappointed.

This pie has Marzano tomatos and buffalo mozzerella from Italy. Once your taste buds become accustomed to these ingredients, you'll crave them. They are simplistic and the highest quality available. The margherita is my favorite.

For you complainers - how many animals must you consume? A vegetarian meal is a good thing. Also - I can't vouch for the service. The time we were there, it was very early, and they were not busy. Our waitress, and everyone else were extrememly nice, and we didn't wait too long. The $21 price is excessive, but the imported ingredients are expensive for sure.

Doesn't Recommend
2.0
over a year ago

The heart of a purest. – I was very disappointed with the pizza. My parents are from Naples, so I was raised on quality ingredients and did appreciate Anthony's attention to detail. I truly like the fact that he keeps everything simple. You will not find meat toppings or other condiments such as garlic powder that will ruin a dish meant to be simple. I feel that Pizza should have a certain ratio of sauce, cheese and crust and in my opinion the crust was just too overwhelming. I dont like a flimsy thick crust , if i want bread with my wine I'll go to a bakery but i was looking for a little more cheese and sauce.The point to a brick oven is a crust with a little crisp to it . I know he uses cheese from Italy which is fine and dandy but its still just pizza. Pizza to me is a comfort food that should be pleasing in both texture and to the taste buds. It was the first time since i was a kid that i did not want to eat the crust. I was sipping wine and who wants to eat dry bread with wine. The price also is a little steep for my taste, and I realize he has to run a wood burning oven, but the thing about pizza is that it should meet a certain pricepoint even with fine ingredients, because its pizza! It was 34.00 $ for a modest glass of wine and a 12 inch pizza. If it were 10.00$ for the whole meal I still will not go back.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Worst Pizza Ever – My taste buds are offended!!!!!! Also 21 dollars for Pizza that tastes like water was spilt on it!!! Don't go here

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

I've just been R@PED!!! – I need to cry but can't muster up the tears. I feel so empty inside. I had to head home to take a hot shower and wash myself clean. I have a terrible taste in my mouth. Not only was I r@ped but I was also robbed. Usually these horrible people get away but this time I know their identities. I must stand up to help stop their terrible acts. I can't let this happen to anyone else!!!

These men were the "wait staff" and "chef" at Una Pizza Napoletana.

My girlfriend and I came for dinner after hearing about them on a "Best of list". We walk in to the very uninviting restaurant and quickly get seated at a table for 4 (next to 2 strangers). We were seriously on top of each other. There we sat for 18 minutes. Yes, I counted. 18 minutes it took before we were ever greeted, given menus or drink orders taken. About 10 minutes later they actually took our order. Why did we need 10 minutes. There were only 4 pizza options (none with actual toppings). We were about to order our pizza to split when I realized the pizzas were 12" personal pizzas that cost $21!!!! Seriously??? The best pizza in the city costs $21 for an 18-20". How could this be? It must be wrong. NOPE. A pizza came out that was a bit smaller than the 12" plate that it was on. Once we cut into the pizza I took a slice and all the "fresh" mozzarella slid off the soggy thin crust. I'm guessing it was olive oil but the entire pizza looked as if it had a glass of water poured onto it. I had never seen that before. The cheese was incredibly chewy and hard to bite through. Ugh. This was seriously the worst pizza that I've had since I moved to NYC.

I feel completely taken advantage of and want to help stop this atrocity. Please pass the word to never go here EVER!!! I would rather go to McDonalds... not because it is cheap but because the food quality is so much better there. Seriously!!!

Please do not take this matter lightly.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

The Educated Palate Need Not Look Further – For those who revel in highest quality ingredients and meticulous attention to detail...read on. Una Pizza's proprietor should be commended for his insistence on holding true to old world traditions regarding the preparation of and the ingredients that compose the pizza he serves. Simplicity is key. Pizza Bianca is not to be missed. Take the rubberbands off your wallet and shell out the bucks for this thin crust. It is well worth it.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Worst Overall Experience – Disappointed, amongst my worst pizza experiences. There are so many better places to go to in the city.

Here are the negatives: 1. very expensive ($21 for a personal size pizza), 2. extremely limited choices (only 4 possibilities, and of course absolutely no toppings/choices) 3. no condiments (ie olive oil, red pepper), 4. no appetizers (so nothing to eat while waiting for 45 mins for pizza), 5. staff attitude, 6. 45 min wait for pizza (seems like they were only able to make 4 small pizzas at a time for a restaurant capacity of 30-40 people).

The only way the experience could have been positive was for the pizza to have been absolutely spectacular ... and it wasnt ... it just okay ... margherita pizza had watery sauce, the crust was half tasty and half deliberately burnt black (is that supposed to make it haute cuisine?) ... had to cut the edges away and dispose.

Never going back. But its one of those things where i think it is fashionable for new yorkers to go there because it is "in" and so they will.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Best Pizza I have ever had!! – I went to this place about 3 years ago. I haven't been back since only because I moved to Los Angeles shortly afterward. Maybe things have changed, but it was the best pizza I have ever had. I loved the simplicity of the space, the wine - it was overall a great experience. The staff were nice as well. It's too bad things have gone south here - for me, it was one of those amazing NYC experiences that I will never forget.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

forget it – I lived in italy half my life, just to state that I do know what I am talking about. I am also not an arrogant person.

But una pizza napoletana is...if it were a person. All staff is arrogant....a snobbish "no" when asked for pepper....a 40 minute wait on a nonbusy Thursday. A variety of four pizzas, none w meat or fish.....each $ 20+

There are at least 40 better pizza restaurants in the same zip code, let alone in the city.

This just shows you what hype and a short opening season during the week does to (some silly) NYers.

Come on, brighten up, smell the fresh pizza elsewhere.

View more Reviews for Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED

Write a Review for

Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOS…


Not rated yet
0 Votes

Best of Citysearch

Won for:
Pizza (2006)
Nominations Nominated for:
Pizza (2008)
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED to Citysearch

Do you have a review of Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED on Citysearch