24 Prince (Reported Closed)

(212) 226-8624 | View Website

24 Prince Street, New York, NY | Directions   10012

40.722871 -73.994574

Open Hours

Tuesday To Friday From 12:00 PM To 05:30 PM Monday To Thursday From 05:30 PM To 11:00 PM Sunday From 05:30 PM To 11:00 PM Friday To Saturday From 05:30 PM To 12:00 AM

 
Restaurants, Traditional American, $$  more

Tags: Bar Scene, Brunch, Late Night Dining, Lunch Spot

Payment Methods: American Express, Debit Card, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Neighborhoods:

less
 
 

Reviews for 24 Prince

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Don't even bother - ignore the hype – My wife and I ate at 24 Prince recently as part of a prix fixe dinner organized by a local winery, each course being paired with a wine. The one positive thing about this evening, was that the food and wine pairings worked well and that was due to the winery staff knowing what they were doing.

The rest of the dining experience was subpar:

- we were seated in the back of the restaurant (as were other diners part of this winery's event) near the restroom and near the back door, where the staff would drag a large garbage pail every hour or so, open the back door, empty the garbage and then drag it back in. The visual appeal of this, coupled with the gust of freezing air left a memorable impression. As did having to look at the people waiting in line for the one bathroom.

- the paper napkins and cheap utensils should have been the tipoff that the worst was yet to come.

- the portions of the first two courses was of a tasting menu size - the dinner was not advertised as a tasting menu so this was surprising.

- since the portions were small, we were still fairly hungry while waiting for our entrees. We noticed other tables had gotten a basket of bread but not us. We asked for some bread and they provided some.

- did I mention that we were waiting for our entrees? At least 20 minutes from the time they cleared the previous course!! We had to remind them and they profusely apologized, but it was too little, too late. In fact, the wine pairing I had received for the entree was finished by the time the entree arrived. The poured us some more, which was expected, but given the place was not that crowded, we were baffled as to why there was such a delay.

- at this point, I was contemplating what kind of tip I should leave - my thoughts hovering around 10% or less (note: I usually leave at least 20% for most dining experiences). When the bill came, I was shocked to see that they had added a 20% gratuity to our bill!! I have seen this for parties of 4 or more, but we were a party of 2. I reluctantly paid this because it may have been the arrangement because of the winery event, but in hindsight, I should have complained. The fact that the staff did this underlines the fact that this place is doomed for failure.

- The wine dinner was advertised as a chance to meet the owner/chef, Nikki Cascone. She was nowhere to be found - never made an "appearance". Not that it would have mattered - we were unimpressed overall. She might be a decent cook, but as the owner of a restaurant, she has failed miserably. She must be too busy planning her upcoming wedding.

I would be very surprised if 24 Prince is still around in 6-12 months. People enjoy good food but you cannot survive on that alone. The attitude and the lack of service and small details (get some decent napkins and cutlery and stop dragging the trash around the dining room!) will kill this place.

I will never be back and will go out of my way to tell as many people as possible to STAY AWAY!!!

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

rip off, bad food – I ate there with a big group, four of us ordered the tuna and each was cooked differently, only one seemed good. The shrimp chop salad had three small pieces of shrimp, and the salad was not chopped. I asked for more sauce, and they came back with a thimble. Portions were very small, and the bill came out to be very large.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

Good Food, Good Service and easy on the wallet – After walking around nolita and visiting the bowery musium I decided to stop at 24 Prince for an early dinner. I had been to 24 Prince for a friends birthday party about a year ago and loved the meatloaf. When we walked in the host sat us right away. Our server was the same server who waited on me at my friends birthday. He was friendly and helpful, he told us some of the must haves on the menu. My friend and I decided to share a flatbread as an app, and for our entree's I had the meatloaf and she had the tuna dish(it looked and smelled great but she would let me taste). The bartender makes a great martini and my friend loved the pear pop. If i wanted to be picky i would say my latte wasn't warm enough but everything else was great and I will be back.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Perfect Spot Rest. – The prices are good for a fine dining restaurant that is usually quiet and casual, the food always tastes good, and they provide excellent waitstaff customer service. I've had the burger and apple & endive, both quite good.Perfect spot.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

My regular brunch spot- go early – I was shopping in nolita and saw the sign about the chef Nikki being on TOP CHEF, had to go in. There was a 15 minute wait but it was worth it. We had my 8 year old son with us and my girlfriend and I enjoyed all of the food. I am only writing this because I saw some of the other reviews and disagreed. i use city search alot and I alwyas see both good and bad reviews i just try to read a lot of them. Try to get their early so there is no wait. It is a very comfortable, affordabel and delicious place.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Lots of Fun - Lots of Good Food & Priced to Please the Pocketbook – A few Sunday's ago my friends and I went to 24 Prince for brunch. We had a great time! The food was great and so was the service. There brunch menu was tasty and priced right. I couldn't wait to tell everyone I know what a great meal I had there. The atmosphere was very New York hip, but comfy & cozy too. I was also excited because I got to meet Nikki, who was a cheftestent on season 4 of "Top Chef" . Alex was our server and he couldn't be more helpful or attentive. The kind of waiter you enjoy giving a good tip to. I also liked the location in this red hot neighborhood close to the Bowery. If you go with friends ask to sit at one of the round tables. It's much more intimate! I recommend 24 Prince for its fun menu & great atmosphere.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

the most awful service, ever... food not that great either – terrible terrible terrible, don't go here. went here for brunch and had to wait for the food for about an hour. took them 30min to make our cocktails while we waited for our food and they had to be repeatedly reminded. the restaurant wasn't even full! the food was ok, but not worth the wait at all. on top of that, when we asked to speak to the manager, the hostess came over instead and LIED to us, saying she is the manager (somebody else told us the manager is a man). she didn't even apologize for the slow service or any other complaints. when we found the real manager, he wasn't very apologetic either. horrible horrible dining experience. not acceptable at all.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Friday night find – So, this is my first restaurant review. Just being honest. I went to 24 prince Friday night for dinner with a good friend. We sat outside in the "backyard", which, while not being full of plants and green things, was a great find considering it was a friday night and we only had to wait 15 minutes and there are NO outside eating places in this neighborhood beside this one, as we discovered walking around the nieghborhood and being told, no, everywhere we went.

The food was good. Actually, very good. Simple, easy and very good. It is not the place that is going to wow you with decadent amazingness, but kind of reminds you of something you could make at home, but, could never make it near as good. Sorry, I'm rambling. But anyways, the food took a long time, my only complaint. Our dessert took at least 20 minutes, which is sad . But it was good.

Regardless of the complaint, the food was very good. The service was amazing. Our server whose name I forget but I think started with an S - Sam - Steve - something like that, was so helpful. He even told us that we had ordered too much food and suggested we order less. and he was right. And, further, he was nice. Not that fake nice, you know, that waiters and waitresses are, but to us, genuinely nice. We asked him what to do in the neighborhood during meal, and when he brought the bill, he brought a list of places and locations where we should go. We are not from New York, so this was amazing.

Sorry to ramble again. But, this restaurant is really good. The back yard-ish area is nice, the service superb and more than knowlegeable, and the feel is very "new york", at least from a seattler's point of view.

Doesn't Recommend
2.0
over a year ago

This is a Top Chef restaurant? – I have had brunch at 24 Prince twice now, and the experience isn't getting any better. The reason I usually end up here is because there is a garden in the back, and it is always nice to eat outside. The first time I ate here I had the baked eggs. My friend ordered the chicken salad. Her sandwich came out quickly, but she was almost finished by the time I got my eggs. Once I did get them, they weren't even cooked all the way. They were runny and wet! The second time I got smart and ordered the truffled chicken salad. It was really good. But my friend ordered a salad that we could have made better at home. Don't expect anything extraordinary out of this place, at least for brunch.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Dismal brunch – Two of us went to 24 Prince for brunch today, and even glimpsed Nikki, the Top Chef contestant popping into the dining room - so we can't excuse the terrible meal based on the idea that the chef wasn't in the kitchen. But the meal was dreadful. The place was nearly empty when we walked in, and there seemed to be a lot of waitstaff around. Throughout the meal they refilled water glasses a million times, but otherwise seemed to be buzzing around trying to figure out what to do.

Coffee was offered quickly and it was fine. We ordered the bread basket while we decided what to order. It took an exceptionally long time for a basket of burnt toast to arrive - setting the stage for their bizarre treatment of bread throughout the meal. Silly me, for six bucks I figured we'd get at least one or two homemade bakery items, but this was a pile of high-end, store bought bread served severely burned.

After a wait the food arrived -- baked eggs that seemed so wet that they were barely baked, and a brioche french toast that seemed that it hadn't even been soaked in eggs, and once again it was burned to a crisp. The french toast looked grim, and tasted worse. We kept the pseudo-baked eggs and sent back the french toast. A replacement plate of scrambled eggs was a much better choice, and even came with some pretty good breakfast potatoes. But it also came with a side of burned toast. What's up with that? They should invest in a quality toaster or just get out of the brunch business.

View more Reviews for 24 Prince

Write a Review for

24 Prince

75% 100 69 67 Votes
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of 24 Prince to Citysearch

Do you have a review of 24 Prince on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your 24 Prince review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the 24 Prince page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

24 Prince on Citysearch