Giorgio's Pizza (Reported Closed)

Quite Possibly the WORST Pizza in NY – I have never consumed pizza that taste this much like cardboard. The cheese literally has no taste, the crust was pale and dry, and the sauce tasted like it came out of a jar of generic tomato sauce sweetened with some kind of generic sugar substitute. And the funny thing is,... I'm not a pizza snob by any means. My co-worker warned me. He told me to go to the shop all the way down on 2nd Ave., but it was cold and somehow Georgio's got an 8.9 rating. Do not be fooled by misled CitySearchers who could even fathom giving this pizza anymore than a rating of 3 - and that is generous. If it came down to it... I would rather spend my money and timing savoring street meat than ever have to revisit this truly disappointing experience.

New York Pizza Rules – I love pizza in New York, where even the mediocre pizza is worth your time and money. The sauce here is too sweet and the crust perhaps a little too thin. Giorgio's was not fantastic, but it hit the spot. Perfect when you're going to a show at Irving Plaza.

Looks like pepperoni – This place is great- right next to Union Square. They drop sauce at random over the whole pie; at first glance, you think it's pepperoni. Definitely not authentic Italian eats, but really good!