The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

(212) 968-1776 | View Website

54 Pearl Street, New York City, NY | Directions   10004

40.703499 -74.011507

Open Hours

M-Su 11:30am-2:30am

 
Pubs, Taverns, Bars & Pubs  more

More Categories: Irish, Traditional American

Neighborhoods: Downtown, Financial District (Wall Street), Financial District

less
 
 
The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern
The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern
The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern
The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

From The Owners of The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

Find out more about us on NearSay


Menu
Tomato and Thyme Bisque, Soup Du Jour, Porterhouse Cheese Board, Farm-Grown Mussels, Chesapeake Bay Crab Cakes, Smoked Atlantic Salmon, Roasted Red and Golden Beets, Jefferson's Cobb, Fraunces Tavern Burger, American Bison Burger... more

Reviews for The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

Recommends

The oldest bar or restaurant in New York, Fraunces Tavern is literally so old that George Washington ate there. The food has changed, but not much, and anyway, it isn't the point. The restaurant is a piece of living history, and to eat roast beef there is to link one's stomach with the founding fathers of the nation. Also, it's excellent roast beef.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

Excellent Historical Dining – AMAZING! I really enjoyed the food...the crab cakes are to die for and the beef wellington is fantastic. My friend got the Beef Roast which was also delicious. The staff are very friendly and helpful with suggestions on price fixe that changes weekly. Can only imagine the the menu. We also asked to see the lunch menu which is different from the dinner to find out that every week Fraunces Tavern offers a $20.09 three course price fixe to be as good as the normal food and for such a good price we are eager to return. Although we only dined in the restaurant side we peeked in the bar which has a back room with a pool table. Seems like a great place to have drinks with a group of friends and enjoy pool. I highly recommend it!

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Rude, Nasty, and Not Worth the Time – Forget the restaurant. Making the reservations was a miserable experience. This nasty and arrogant "girl" answers the phone, puts me on hold for 5 minutes, comes back on the phone while chomping on food, huffing and puffing while I am asking the latest time to get reservations because I am lecturing that night, and then when I ask her if I am being a bother because she obviously doesn't want to be on the phone - she HANGS UP THE PHONE. So, I call back completely enraged and demand to speak to a manager. Apparently, Mr. Napolean complex as he is being described in all the reviews gets on the phone and refuses to account for this girl hanging up on me. He DEFENDS her and says she tried putting me on hold. I was persistent in making the point. He didn't want to listen. After about 5 minutes of going back and forth with this guy, and ARGUING (HE IS ARGUING WITH A PATRON), he says, do you want reservations or what? Then when I say I WANT THE LATEST POSSIBLE TIME FOR RESERVATIONS, he says, he will be working and I won't be happy so he will NOT take my reservations. AND HANGS UP THE PHONE.

Don't even think about going to this place. They changed management and apparently scooped up NYC's worst and rudest possible people. Go to another restaurant it is not worth it.

I have no gain in lying. Trust me, please. I wouldn't take time to write this review if I wasn't being sincere.

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT! – My husband and I came to New York for a talk at the Met on Dutch Art. My husband is an artist who works in Still life and Interiors. One of our goals was to visit the Frauncus Tavern, which was presented as an elegant historical museum and restaurant by their website.

We got to the area, after much traffic and expensive parking, only to find it closed. We were very disappointed so we ate elsewhere. On our way back to our car, we saw that it was open so we were delighted and decided to go in and have something simple just to experience the lovely setting.

We were the only people there. Rock and roll music was being piped into the lovely 1700's tavern side, which totally ruined any attempt at conversation so we moved to the dining room, which was quieter but you could still hear the loud music.

We ordered soup, bread and a beer. The waiter was bored and unattentive. We tried not to let it spoil it for us. After we ate, we asked for the check several times, as we had to get our car out of the garage or pay another $ 15.00. We had a half hour to go next door and get the car. We asked three times for the check to no avail. (Remember there was not another soul in the place.) Finally I stood up and went up to the hostess, who was talking on the phone and ignored me and finally said in a loud voice, "Could we please have our check." This brought the check but we waited 15 more minutes for the change, no luck...asked again..told by the girl "I already told them you wanted the change, they're working on it!" It took 3 tries to get the change, with the older man from the kitchen literally hollering at us about how we couldn't wait!!

As we left, the group of 3, the hostess, the waiter and the rude man stood in the foyer talking loudly about what "jerks" we were..the man said, "what the hell did they expect, they only ordered the soup!"

I expected good service, nice ambiance, and a historical experience. I didn't get any of it. Don't waste your time here

Doesn't Recommend
1.0
over a year ago

Needs New Management – My coworkers and I have been holding happy hours at this place for the past 2 years and have seen it rapidly go downhill until it reached rock bottom last week. The bartenders and waitresses used to be awesome, greeting us by name, never messing up orders etc but most have been replaced by inexperienced people who constantly mess up orders and "accidently" slip drinks on our tab. This has happened on several occasions. The breaking point however, was the other night when the snobby manager with the Napolean complex kicked us out of one section of the lounge because a more important party was coming. Mind you, this party was three hours late for their reservation and the manager had no qualms about our party using the space (and dishing out money) while they were on their way but as soon as they came, we were basically expected to guzzle our drinks and shoo out of "the reserved area" to make way for Goldman Sachs. YES, the manager actually named dropped as if we were supposed to be impressed! He is basically a greedy little man who should've closed off the whole area in the first place if he were to really honor a groups reservation- not squeeze as much money as possible out of people in a given amount of time.

He lost a large group of regulars with his bad attitude. I wouldn't be surprised if he's the reason, the awesome bartenders and waitresses are no longer there.

In conclusion, spend your money elsewhere. Don't contribute to this poor man's ill-fitting suits tailored from the boys section of Bloomingdales.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

Surprisingly Classy! – I work in the Financial District and most places to eat around here are quite seedy. A friend was visiting for lunch one day and I took her to Fraunces, expecting the usual pub food and atmosphere based on the word "Tavern" in the name. We were very surprised to find ourselves ushered into a nice dining room full of older men conducting business meetings at tables covered in clean linen cloths. As two casually dressed twenty something ladies we felt very out of place. Prices were more than what we were expecting in the area but they fit the fare as the food was very good. Service was fantastic as well. We both had salads. They were delicious.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

NYC's historical past – New York City is one of the oldest cities in what is today the United States. Yet as most NYC residents and tourists can testify to New York is also a city constantly on the move, always exhibiting the modern while keeping some essence of its past. Fraunces Tavern Museum is a source of this essence. It is the one location in New York whether visitors can get a glimpse of how New York fight alongside cities famous for their role in the Revolutionary conflict of the 18th century such as Philadelphia and Boston.

Although it is relatively small in comparision to the Metropolitan Museum and even the Museum of the City of New York, Fraunces Tavern museum has intriguing and informative exhibitions that both educate and intrigue visitors. Exhibits ranging from African American participation in the Revolutionary War to their famous historically restored "Long Room" where General Washington met, ate, and drink with his officers, give a view of life in early New York City being just as vibrant and busy as the city has always been known as. For all these reason, Fraunces Tavern is one the city's precious historical gems.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

This unassuming museum, tucked away above the more famous restaurant, is a hidden gem. – As you walk over creaking (unfortunately non-original) floorboards of the oldest building in Manhattan, it's fascinating to imagine what lower Manhattan, the cradle of European settlement in New York, must have been like as a skyscraper-less, bustling seaport. The museum is most striking when it plays to the visitor's visual-historical imagination in this way: the heart of the museum is the "Long Room" where George Washington said farewell to his officers at the end of the war, and is set up like a colonial tavern. Informative placards and video recount the function of 18th century taverns and the history of Sam Fraunces' Tavern (history buffs will be thrilled at how many key events the tavern witnessed). Kids and pass-through visitors will really enjoy this, as well as the muskets and flag gallery upstairs.

For the slower museum-goer, too, there are a surprising number of fascinating

paintings, prints, and documents (mostly on the easy-to-miss third story), all

arranged very intelligently to make one think about our revolutionary history

in new ways. The collection of 18th and 19th century prints of George

Washington shows the near-deification of our most beloved founder,

and also the process by which images were copied and re-copied in that day.

The Heroes exhibit contains paintings from mostly 19th and 20th centuries, provoking the visitor to think about the elements of historical painting and the way it (and we as a culture) tells its stories. The exhibit also suggests that the people fighting for American independence were of a variety of nations, classes, genders, and ethnicities.

The current rotating exhibit, on African-American involvement in the Revolution, expands on this last theme, and raises questions about the practical difficulties of bringing the American slave economy in line with the freedom rhetoric of the Revolution.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

Hidden Treasure – I attended a rehearsal dinner at the Tavern towards the end of March 2006 in one of the private rooms. I was pleasantly surprised. The food, the service and the decor were all top notch. There is a very friendly and knowledgeable staff in regards to the rich history that the Tavern represents. I have been back twice and have not been disappointed. I would highly recommend trying it for your self. Whether it is a party of 2 or a party of 200....this is the place to have it. I just wish I lived closer...I would certainly become a regular.

Recommends
4.0
over a year ago

beautiful experience – I went here late night with a friend and was surprised that they were still seating. The staff was kind and prompt and the food was great. I loved how historica everything was, from the seats, to the lamps, even the cultery had a flair for class. I throughly enjoyed my experience here.

Recommends
5.0
over a year ago

A Very Old Flame Brightly Burns – Fraunces Tavern is a terrific place to spoon and dine with the same fireplace the original G-Dubs set himself afront lit warmly in the spacious, elegant, aged oldest retaurant in New York City.

Washington said goodbye to his troops here, but this is a great place for an unforgettable hello!

Enjoy the ale, and history!

View more Reviews for The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

Write a Review for

The Porterhouse at Fraunce…

U.S.A! U.S.A! Ten All-American Restaurants to Celebrate the Fourth of July Feeling patriotic? Want to celebrate our great nation\'s unique liberties and noble achievements?…
East Side, West Side, All Around the Town: The Restaurants of Old New York The glory of our city is in its history, which presses down upon us from angle, as omnipresent as…
80% 100 23 20 Votes
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern to Citysearch

Do you have a review of The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern on Citysearch