1114 Lexington Ave, New York, NY | Directions 1002140.771581 -73.961364
Neighborhoods: Midtown, Upper East Side
Amazing Catering, Effort free, Great food – I just used Butterfield to cater an intimate thanksgiving for 17 people and my guests (and me) can't stop raving about how wonderful everything was. First of all, they took care of all the details, from soup to nuts. The prices were very reasonable, the food came, on time, when promised. The deliveryman was pleasant, courteous and diligent, but most importantly, the food was amazing! Everything was cooked to perfection. The side dishes were creative, tasty and the deserts were out of this world. I have found myself a new caterer. I have used many other caterers around the city for occasions like this, but when a friend raved about Butterfield, I thought I'd give them a try and I couldn't be more pleased. Thank you, Butterfield, for making this a very memorable Thanksgiving.
Best Catered Meal, No it was the best meal I have ever had, I will contract them again and again. – We came into NY to visit with our children for Thanksgiving. We were a large group or 17 for dinner so they hired Butterfields to cater the meal. We have eaten at many of New York?s finest restaurants for various holidays and without any exceptions this was absolutely the best meal we have ever had the pleasure of eating. The turkey was moist, the sweet potatoes were flavored with praline, they were better than my Mothers (sorry Mom). The vegetables were perfect as well. The portions were very generous and yes we had leftovers for turkey sandwiches the next day. Then came the pies, I love Pecan pie and am quite the connoisseur THIS WAS THE BEST we also had Apple, Lemon and Pumpkin, all great. The value was the best we have ever paid as well, I don?t know how they can make such a great meal for the money we paid. I will definitely contract them again the next time we visit New York.
Best Caterer in NYC – I have used many different caterers in NYC and have never been happier than I was with Butterfield Market's Catering Division. Whether a large benefit dinner or a small intimate gathering in my home I know I can always depend upon Butterfield Market.
Great Food, Great Staff, Great Part – Butterfield Market made having a party fun again!!
Not only was the food excellent, but also the staff was very personable and professional. I did not have to worry about a thing.
I will definitely book them again.
Great Thanksgiving Day Dinner from Butterfield Market – I catered Thanksgiving Day dinner today from Butterfield Market, after selecting it from a list of caterers reviewed by New York Magazine. The dinner arrived today during the day, the Turkey warm so all i had to do was reheat it at 350 degrees for 15 minutes before people arrived. I also had to reheat the sides the same way.
They forgot to include the cranberry sauce, so I called, and within a couple hours Butterfield delivered that single item to me. No hassles. Also, when I got the meal, the containers looked quite small so I got a bit concerned that it wouldn't be enough. But, to get to the bottomline, the meal was perfect.
My family is hard to please and have made comments about other caterers of previous years (also which I had selected from New York Magazine). This one, everyone agreed, the food was excellent. Everything was perfect. I'd probably opt for the apple pie next time over the pumpkin pie (i got both this time), but regardless this caterer was clearly superior. I would highly recommend catering from Butterfield Market. Note that it's not cheap. And there was a $50 delivery fee (at least for my location). But it proved worth it.
We all agreed that we'd order from Butterfield again. Frankly, I still feel full at the moment, so it's hard to think about ordering for next year at the moment!
a great market for catering – i catered thanksgiving dinner from them last year
everything was absolutely delicious. the service was fantastic and i was able to get in and out of there because of it's location. i'd highly recommend this place to anybody
and if you manage to go and order from this place, make sure you try the sweet potato praline, it's one of the best dishes you'll ever eat.
Staple Business On Upper East Side – This neighborhood store has the best prepared food in the neighborhood. I recently went to a friends house where the Butterfield Market catered a cocktail party, and was impressed not only by the waiters, and professionalism of the event - but that the food was even better than it is in the store!
best in the city – this place has the most delicious chicken fingers, fruit, cappachinos, and friendly service... the cakes are great the best!
Great store – I have been a customer for over 30 years. The food quality is superb, the produce is exceptional, and the family that owns the store add to the aptmosphere.
My Favorite Store – I just moved to New York about 2 years ago from a small town in New Jersey. Most of the stores in manhattan are so inpersonal it was nice to find a real neighborhoods market that I feel at home in. I sometime feel like "Norm" from Cheers. The food is always great, but what I love most about it is the people.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Butterfield Market on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.