796 Lexington Ave, New York, NY | Directions 1002140.763908 -73.967152
Neighborhoods: Upper East Side, Lenox Hill, Midtown
Got me back into comics – Gotham City Comics got me back into collecting comics. I was a big collector as a kid, but stopped when my comic shop was knocked out by the bigger stores. I tried switching to the big stores for a little, but I soon realized that half my enjoyment of being a comic collector was going to the store on Wednesday and hanging out. Even after 2 years at the bigger stores nobody knew me. I had pretty much stopped collecting until one day i walked into Gotham City comics. The atmosphere was just like my old shop. By the second week Bernie, the owner, greeted me by name as i walked in. I have been a loyal customer ever since. Bernie always makes sure to add books to my pile that he thinks I will enjoy and always orders books for me if I missed something. I look forward to Wednesdays not just for my books, but to comics and just hang out with the crew.
I wish there were more places like Gotham City Comics!
I love small shops but this one is no good – The guy named johnny who works the counter is a real piece of work. I realize the camp value of a rude comic book guy but this is too much. The store stock is very low in current weekly comics. I partially blame direct sales but "johnny" acted like it was my problem and not his.
Front-runner For Worst Comics Shop in NYC – One more vote for DON'T SHOP HERE.
I walked in expecting to find a normal small comics shop with some back issues and maybe some interesting things. I walked in and was appalled at how disorganized and haphazardly all the merchandise was displayed. Very few things of interest were in the store and what was good was exhorbitantly price gouged, since apparently the owner learned nothing from the comics market crash in the mid-90s.
I began to flip through a box of back issues since they weren't marked with any sort of label saying they weren't supposed to be flipped through and the owner(I assume anyhow), came over and went into a passive aggressive hissy fit and said in an angered voice that no one except him was supposed to flip through the merchandise and that if I was looking to just "pass time" I should "go to Barnes and Noble or Borders." Not letting me look through the back issue bins would've been fine except a) He didn't label them as being off-limits, b) they were 99% overprinted 90s garbage anyway, not pieces in the MOMA and c) he didn't have to be angry/passive-aggressive towards me to the point that I had to leave his store. How this man stays in business baffles me. With the poor selection, poor organization, poor pricing, and atrocious to outright offensive customer service, it'd be best to bring your business to other, friendlier, and better run shops.
Gotham City Comics makes me ashamed to be a comic book collector.
User review by brotherbeat – i have been buying comics since i was 8, going to comic specialty shops since i was fifteen and gotham is the only place where the staff asked my name and remembered from week to week. i went there initially because it was convenient and continued because of their subscription service and because i like i shop where the customers want to hang-out and discuss the randomness of their interests. despite the size, the selection is pretty good, and things can be ordered. the only real downside is the lack of comfortable seating for hanging out.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Gotham City Comics on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.