Papa Jake's

(716) 874-3878

1672 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY | Directions   14207

42.942355 -78.878840

Open Hours

Sun 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Mon 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Tue 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Wed 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Thu 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Fri 11:00 AM-04:00 AM;Sat 11:00 AM-04:00 AM

Traditional American, Seafood, American Express  more

More Payment Methods: Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Categories: Bars & Clubs, Bars & Pubs, Taverns, Catering, Restaurants, Grill Restaurants

Neighborhoods: Black Rock


Reviews for Papa Jake's

5 months ago

Miss you Chris ! Guys from Gioia

over a year ago

Good Business – It was nice to read the reviews even though they were troubling, but since I was just at Papa Jake's last night with a table of 10 I thought I better write something about our experience.

We had no complaints. Our bartender/waiter was super, we never waited for a drink. All our food came out at the same time and it was totally awesome. We all plan on going there again next week!

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

BAD BUSINESS – Papa Jakes needs to concentrate on gaining the integrity the business lacks. We had a "Seize the Deal" coupon for which we paid $20. Although the coupon said right on it that it expired on Oct 26, Papa Jakes said that they changed the expiration to Oct 25 and would not take it. Not only did we not get our $40 in food that we expected - but we are out the $20 we paid and got nothing for it. Papa Jakes I'm sure got their portion of our money for delivering nothing but difficulty. Seize the Deal is not answering their phones and I will never go to a shady business like Papa Jakes again.

over a year ago

Awesome place to catch a bite and a drink – I was personaly sitting next to the lunatic lady from the previous review and I can say that she is lying flat out. She border line assulted the hostess who was extremely nice to us it is pathetic when low lives try to get a free meal. In addition I go to papa Jakes 3 times a week and have never had a bad to the lady of the previous reveiw get a life and some friends and maybe you will not be so mad all the time

Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

Go Elsewhere! – Was a regular.... with 4-5 others every other Friday generally. The service and food quality started to get poor so we stopped going. Haven't been there in a few years, but heard Jakes has a new owner. So we thought we would give it another shot! Wow! Things got worse!

I mean Wow!

Read on!

This is a restaurant....... food service ...... there are some basics. Like.... Good management, food to serve, enough help, enough knives and forks, enough glasses and the help/management should not be nibbling and eating off of the food plated and waiting to be served. Especially when the customers can sit at the table at the entrance of the kitchen (no door) and watch this going on. It would also be nice if the help had enough manners to not pick at the customers food waiting to be served with knives that were just in their mouth!

Two people at our table witnessed that happen this evening. 8-27-10. We confronted the help/manager who we just watched do that and he flatly denied it. 2 people at our table in perfect view within 10'! It must happen so often he does not even realize he is doing this OR that it is wrong! Neither is acceptable.

We were asked to leave. Thank you actually! So Let's review........

No food! ......poor service! help! glasses or flatware!...... and a manager/(owner?) who would rather pick at the customers food with dirty utensils than pitch in and help wash to get what limited equipment out to the customers!

Get me out of there!

Leaving was the best thing that could have happened.

Like the other reviewer said. "This is Buffalo there are LOTS of great restaurants for Friday Fishfrys"

We are good for at least $3000. per year (Min $60x50) just for Friday Fishfrys. Not another nickel here!

Count on it!

You may think you had a great meal there...but were you actually watching? We were and it was disgusting! What are we not seeing in there?

Want to guess what happened to the food we ordered and never got??


Doesn't Recommend
over a year ago

WHat Hapeened to Papa Jake's? – What happened to Papa Jake's?

It used to have the nicest bartender and wait people! The food was always decent pub food and we especially enjoyed the meatloaf sandwich and breaded fish fry.

Our last couple visits have left us missing the good old Papa Jake's. An extremely rude and bratty hostess and and unfriendly bartender are enough to keep me away but the mediocre food sealed the deal. Too bad because this was a favorite meeting place for our family.

Lucky for us this is Buffalo and it's not hard to find friendly bartenders, hostesses that know what being a hostess means and wait people that provide excellent service! Oh and above average pub food!

My advice: don't bother coming here anymore. Suggestions for a replacement meeting place? Send 'em and thanks!

over a year ago

Editorial Review by Christy Buena – Locals flock for grilled meatloaf and tuna steak sandwiches as well as the full selection of bottled and draft beers.


Write a Review for

Papa Jake's

50% 100 10 6 Votes

Best of Citysearch

Nominated for:
Cheap Eats (2006)
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of Papa Jake's to Citysearch

Do you have a review of Papa Jake's on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your Papa Jake's review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the Papa Jake's page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

Papa Jake's on Citysearch