My Tomato Pie Inc

(716) 838-0969 | View Website

3085 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY | Directions   14226

42.980435 -78.818484

Open Hours

Mon. - Thu., Sun. 11am - 9:30pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 10:30pm

Pizza, Italian, $  more

Payment Methods: American Express, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Categories: Catering, Restaurants


Personal 7", Small 13", Large 17”, Your Calzone, Sausage Calzone, Chicken Calzone, Deli Calzone, Portobello C a Lzon E, Hawallan Calzone, Chicken Finger Calzone... more

Reviews for My Tomato Pie Inc

over a year ago

One of my favorite places in Buffalo – A welcoming atmosphere with a Mom and Pop feel.

If yor have never been there, you must will find yourself returning often

over a year ago

Will def be back – Went there once then took a freind there. WOW we had a small pizza, steak and peppers, cheese toppings. We ate it all, the best part was we didnt feel all bloated like you do with any other pizza, this was delicious, lite and filling all at the same time. A great flaky and crispy crust, great, fresh toppings. Cloth napkins, nice touch, wait staff professional and very attentive. The owner knows how to please!

over a year ago

I am a Pizza Bread Junkie! – Great Food - especially sandwiches, soups, salads. I highly recommend strawberry goat cheese salad. Pizza is good, it has a homemade taste. Pizza Bread is beyond great- especially when you are dining in and it comes right out of the oven. Service is fantastic- waitresses remember regulars; all friendly except for one that doesn't smile. Family friendly. They use cloth napkins which adds a nice touch. It is our standby restaurant, when in doubt- go to Tomato Pie! ( Lots of options for Vegetarians, too!)

over a year ago

Thank You! – As the owner of My Tomato Pie, I would like to thank all my customers who have supported us over the last nine years. It is you that have made us one of Buffalo?s #1 Independently Owned Restaurants. Without you, our excellent homemade food would only be enjoyed by friends and family who have kept these recipes secret for generations and generations.

I have been lucky enough to prepare many very special meals for you and your families. As many of my family recipes? have been used for your special meals in the restaurant, our banquet rooms, or possibly catered right at your house.

As I continue to serve your family, your friends, and you, please show your support by giving us feedback. Let me know if you ever want me to run a special that you might be craving, or even tell me if we could have been a little better.

Our menu has developed through the years because of your feedback, so please keep it coming.



over a year ago

I loved the garlic bread with tomatoes and spinach – Very quaint, nice atmosphere and the best garlic bread with spinach and tomatoes I have had in a while!

over a year ago

Editorial Review – Gourmet pizza, pasta, focaccia sandwiches, homemade desserts and fried green tomatoes, plus beer and wine.

over a year ago

Good – Have had some good sandwichs. Services was good and prices were reasonable.

over a year ago

Great Value – Great family restaurant. The kids will love the macaroni & cheese or the great individual pizzas. The food is great and the services is friendly. And the prices are great! You can actually afford to bring the kids!! They have a frequent diner program too, which helps if you eat out regularly.

over a year ago

Thanks for a great meal. – Your chicken Foccacia sandwich is the best. My girlfriend also loves your Tomato Basil Soup.

over a year ago

Wow! – I have dined at My Tomato Pie on several ocations and each time I am overly impressed with my food, service and overall experience. I travel all over the country and wish there was something like this outside of Buffalo. Their unique food selection and ability to reproduce the same high quality over and over is amazing. I highly recommend this resturant to others.

View more Reviews for My Tomato Pie Inc

Write a Review for

My Tomato Pie Inc

92% 100 18 12 Votes

Best of Citysearch

Won for:
American Restaurant (2009)
Brunch (2009)
Buffet (2009)
Business Lunch and Dinner Restaurant (2009)
Dessert Spot (2009)
Family Friendly Restaurant (2009)
Group Dining (2009)
Italian Food (2009)
Lunch Spot (2009)
Meat 'n Three Restaurant (2009)
Mediterranean Food (2009)
People Watching (2009)
Pizza (2009)
Restaurant (2009)
Romantic Restaurant (2009)
Small Plates (2009)
Vegetarian Food (2009)
Wine List (2009)
Group Dining (2005)
Nominations Nominated for:
Cheesesteak (2009)
Cheap Eats (2006)
Group Dining (2006)
Italian Food (2006)
Pizza (2006)
Italian Food (2005)
Pizza (2005)
Get Directions
Your Friends

Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!

Add Blog Post

Add your blog review of My Tomato Pie Inc to Citysearch

Do you have a review of My Tomato Pie Inc on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:

  • 1. Include our image link in your My Tomato Pie Inc review blog post.
  • 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
  • 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the My Tomato Pie Inc page on Citysearch.

The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.

Read our FAQ for details.

Image Link

To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.

My Tomato Pie Inc on Citysearch