150 Eastbrook Rd, Smoketown, PA | Directions 1757640.034816 -76.197683
Open Monday thru Saturday
11:30am - 8:00pm
Sunday 11:30am - 5:00pm, Seasonally
Good 'N Plenty lives up to it's name. It's an all you can eat, family style restaurant, that serves up traditional Amish foods. They have a bake shop and gift store located within the building. It is closed for a couple of months in the winter, but I highly recommend stopping by any other time of the year
Me and my Family was on our way back from Cape May, NJ from vacation in June of 2012. My girlfriend mentioned going to good 'N plenty restaurant. I never heard of it. She said it is really good and her dad loves the bean salad. They usually go during the firemens expo in harrisburg. Well anyways. We went to good 'N plenty, me, my girlfriend, and the kids went there to go eat dinner from such a long drive and still had 5 more hours to go before we hit our hometown Pittsburgh, PA. When we got there they seated us and at first i kinda felt weird sitting beside and eating with strangers lol. When she said it was all you can eat buffet i thought we was actually going to be seated together and go and grab our food. WELL let me just say after sitting beside two strangers at a large banquet table and started to have conversations with them i started to feel comfortable and it felt like we was all a family and friends. The food was out of this world. I can not describe how superb it was. My taste buds was exploding with flavor of delicious food. We had Roast Beef,(that was so moist and tender) Corn, Mash Potatoes, Butter Noodles, Bean Salad, & Desserts. Let me just tell you it was the best homemade cooking i have ever had in a very long time. I was Raving over the butter Noodles it was the BEST. (let me just add i have the butter noodle recipe LOL) It had like a sweet kinda taste and i couldn't stop eating them. I was soo fool after i left that place it was well worth it and the money.
Good service. Food was Tasty and warm. Angie was pleasant and helpful.
We have been making a point to visit Good & Plenty when in the Lancaster area for years. Food is always authentic and delicious. Service is always with a smile. But, you must be prepared for the Family Style dining. We have met some nice people seated at our table.... Be open-minded and enjoy!
We were visiting from Canada and stayed here on the American Thanksgiving. They served an Amish family feast to tables of 12 and it was DELICIOUS. Great down-home cooking and delicious desserts!! All at an inexpensive price as well....... I will difinitely eat here again.
The food was good and there was plenty to choose from. The staff at the Wingate was excellent with directions and suggested this restaurant.
Pleasantly greeted, pleasant waitress ( knowledgeable ) overall pleasant experience
We were delighted with the food here! We thought it was good value as the price included drinks and dessert. The staff was friendly too
We eat at Gn'P almost every trip we make to Lancaster county! You never get tired of that great food!! It's always delicious, & plenty of it!! Price is right, & great variety! What more can you ask for?!?!
Wow! We had an all you can eat family-style dinner with amazingly moist turkey and gravy, fried chicken, and pork and sauerkraut. After dinner they had cheesecake, homemade ice cream, shoo fly pie, pudding, and pumpkin pie for dessert, and all were excellent. We were very pleased with the quality of the food and the service and would definitely go back!!!
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Good 'N Plenty Restaurant on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.